DESI Presentation: Q&A
- Posted by: Ken Phelps
- Published on: September 8, 2009
Today I conducted an audio conference entitled: FDA banning DESI Drugs-Submissions Strategies to Keep Yours on the Market. I know, a bit aggressive, but it’s also a crowded market. Judging from the questions, most attendees are current DESI producers looking to gain knowledge of the pathway to FDA approval. As we have tracked in this blog (search DESI) FDA is moving against DESI drugs and DESI producers are wondering if their products are next on the chopping block.
We had several good questions which I’d like to share a few of general interest (I’ll paraphrase to get the most value for our readers).
- Will a 505(b)(2) of a DESI receive exclusivity? Yes, the source of an NDA is not the determining factor in granting exclusivity to an NDA. Any NDA, 505(b)(1) or (b)(2) can be granted 3 years exclusivity for an NDA that requires a clinical study or 5 years exclusivity for a new chemical entity; there are a lot of NCE DESI candidates.
- How long after an NDA is approved will it take for FDA to remove the competing unapproved products? We don’t know. There are no guarantees that they will eliminate the competitors, but their policy guide indicates they should.
- Are DESI > NDA under user fee? Yes, all NDA’s are subject to user fees (PDUFA). PDUFA allows for no fee for the 1st NDA from a small business (defined as less than 500 employees).
- Aren’t PDUFA fees excessive for DESI companies that wish to file an NDA for several products? PDUFA provides for a full or partial waiver for the fee when an economic case can be made.
- Is there a list of DESI products? No list is available. Most people don’t distinguish between a DESI that went through the review process and those that haven’t yet been reviewed or are identical, related or similar to an approved or pending DESI. A review of the Federal Register from 1966-1969 can get a ‘list’ of products that were reviewed, but the ultimate decision of the review is hard to locate. 20 of the initial 30 drug categories still have not been fully completed.
- How do you determine a budget for a DESI > NDA? Seriously folks, I didn’t plant this question as infomercial. Camargo clients know that the answer is to conduct an assessment study and then present the gap analysis to FDA to obtain the Agency’s concurrence.
The assessment study reviews the public domain and develops arguments why selected data can be used for pivotal information in an NDA. Using what we know for the approval of similar drug, we establish the gap – the studies needed by the sponsor and estimate the cost and duration of each study. This study is then wrapped into a submission for a pre-IND meeting where we also list questions for the FDA to address. After the pre-IND meeting, a sponsor will know what the requirements will be.